Third-Party Risk ManagementNov 17, 202611 min read

How to use security ratings in vendor due diligence

resources.items.ratingsDueDiligence.heroAlt
CR

CyberRank Research

Part of: Free Security Rating

Use security ratings in vendor due diligence as an independent first screen: rate every candidate vendor before contract, set a minimum rating for each risk tier, use the findings to target your questionnaire, and keep monitoring after onboarding. Ratings do not replace questionnaires, contracts or audits, but they make each of those steps faster and better informed. They also give you evidence that does not depend on the vendor's own answers. CyberRank provides AAA–D ratings for any organisation from its domain, with nightly monitoring once a vendor is onboarded.

TL;DR

  • A security rating is an outside-in posture indicator; in due diligence it screens, focuses and monitors.
  • Set minimum ratings by vendor tier, and define what happens when a vendor falls short.
  • Combine ratings with questionnaires, certificates and contract terms; each covers a different gap.
  • Judge a rating provider on methodology transparency, coverage, monitoring frequency, dispute handling and privacy coverage.
  • CyberRank rates vendors from a domain, monitors them nightly and can send questionnaires automatically to vendors below your baseline.

What role does a security rating play in vendor due diligence?

Vendor due diligence is the set of checks you perform before and during a supplier relationship to decide whether the vendor's risk is acceptable. A security rating is one input: an evidence-based view of the vendor's observable posture.

Security ratings sit inside third-party risk management, as defined in our glossary. Their value comes from being independent, quick and repeatable. The table below shows how a rating is used at each stage. For a refresher on the method itself, see our explainer on outside-in security assessments.

Security ratings across the due diligence life cycle
ShortlistingHow a rating is usedCompare candidate vendors on the same scaleOther evidence neededBusiness fit, referencesHow CyberRank helpsRates any vendor from its domain in minutes
Pre-contract assessmentHow a rating is usedCheck against the tier's minimum ratingOther evidence neededQuestionnaire, certificates, data-flow reviewHow CyberRank helpsQuestionnaire builder with evidence upload
ContractingHow a rating is usedAgree remediation deadlines for open findingsOther evidence neededSecurity and data protection clausesHow CyberRank helpsFindings with severity and fix guides to attach
OnboardingHow a rating is usedRecord the baseline ratingOther evidence neededAccess approvalsHow CyberRank helpsRating history from day one
Ongoing monitoringHow a rating is usedDetect rating drops, new breaches, privacy-policy changesOther evidence neededPeriodic questionnaire refreshHow CyberRank helpsNightly reassessment with alerts
Renewal or exitHow a rating is usedReview the trend, not just today's gradeOther evidence neededPerformance and incident historyHow CyberRank helpsRating history timeline and reports

The same evidence at every stage

How CyberRank helps: the same rating and findings follow the vendor through every stage, so evidence does not have to be rebuilt each time.

Why do regulators expect this kind of evidence?

Most supplier-risk rules ask you to assess suppliers proportionately and keep monitoring them. They do not require security ratings by name, but ratings are a practical way to produce evidence for several of their requirements.

See our pages on NIS2 supply chain security, ISO 27001 and OJK outsourcing for detail on each framework below. How CyberRank helps: CyberRank gives evidence for these requirements; it does not make you compliant with them.

Supplier-risk requirements a rating can support
NIS2, Article 21(2)(d) and 21(3)Relevant requirementSupply chain security; take account of suppliers' vulnerabilities and cybersecurity practicesHow a rating supports itIndependent evidence about each direct supplier's exposureHow CyberRank helpsSupplier ratings with findings
DORA, Article 28Relevant requirementAssess ICT third-party providers before contracting and monitor themHow a rating supports itPre-contract and ongoing posture evidenceHow CyberRank helpsPre-contract rating and nightly monitoring
ISO/IEC 27001:2022, controls 5.19–5.22Relevant requirementSupplier security requirements, ICT supply chain, monitoring of supplier servicesHow a rating supports itMonitoring evidence for 5.22How CyberRank helpsAssurance Statement referencing controls 5.21 and 5.22
Indonesia: OJK rules on outsourcing and UU PDPRelevant requirementManage outsourcing risk; protect personal data handled by processorsHow a rating supports itEvidence about vendors handling customer dataHow CyberRank helpsPrivacy and security sub-ratings, UU PDP indicators

How should you set a minimum rating for vendors?

A minimum rating only works if it reflects how much damage a vendor could do. Tie thresholds to tiers, not to a single company-wide grade.

Our article on which vendors to review first explains how to tier vendors by impact. In the fictional example below, a mid-sized Indonesian insurer uses three tiers. The thresholds are illustrative, not a recommendation for your organisation.

Example (fictional): minimum ratings by vendor tier
CriticalExample vendorsCore policy system host, payment processorMinimum ratingAIf below minimumNo contract until remediated, or senior risk sign-off with a dated plan
HighExample vendorsCRM provider, claims outsourcing partnerMinimum ratingBIf below minimumContract with a remediation clause and a 90-day re-check
StandardExample vendorsOffice supplies, event agencyMinimum ratingCIf below minimumAccept; monitor for new breaches only

Thresholds in tenders

CyberRank's glossary entry on Rating A versus Rating B notes that some tenders already set a minimum rating of B. How CyberRank helps: CyberRank combines an impact tier with breach likelihood to give a risk level and a heat map, which makes tier-based thresholds easier to apply.

How do you combine ratings with questionnaires and certificates?

No single source of evidence covers everything. Use ratings to decide which questions to ask.

A vendor with a clean external posture and a current ISO/IEC 27001 certificate may need a short questionnaire; a vendor with exposed services needs detailed questions and remediation evidence. Our article on what an external security scan checks explains how to read those findings. For privacy-specific checks, see our guide to vendor privacy risk assessment. The matrix below shows which source answers which question.

Which evidence answers which question
Is the public footprint secure today?RatingStrongQuestionnaireWeak (self-reported)Certificate or audit reportWeak (point in time)How CyberRank helpsOutside-in findings
Are governance and policies in place?RatingNot visibleQuestionnaireStrongCertificate or audit reportStrongHow CyberRank helpsQuestionnaire builder
Do controls operate over time?RatingPartial (external only)QuestionnaireWeakCertificate or audit reportStrong (for audited scope)How CyberRank helpsCertificate detection and upload with expiry dates
Has the vendor been breached?RatingStrong (public breaches)QuestionnaireDepends on honestyCertificate or audit reportNot coveredHow CyberRank helpsBreach history from public databases
Where is our data hosted?RatingPartial (hosting signals)QuestionnaireStrongCertificate or audit reportPartialHow CyberRank helpsAllowed jurisdictions and hosting countries
Who are the vendor's own suppliers?RatingPartial (fourth parties observed)QuestionnaireStrongCertificate or audit reportWeakHow CyberRank helpsFourth parties with ratings

Automating the follow-up

How CyberRank helps: CyberRank can send questionnaires automatically to vendors whose rating falls below your baseline.

How do you evaluate a security rating provider?

If you are choosing a ratings provider, compare like with like. The criteria below matter more than the headline grade.

Ask each provider for a sample report and the evidence behind one finding. How CyberRank helps: CyberRank's own answers are in the last column of the table below, and its limits are described further down.

Criteria for evaluating a security rating provider
Methodology transparencyWhat to askIs the scoring method published and explainable?Why it mattersYou must defend decisions to auditors and vendorsHow CyberRank answers itIISRI® methodology; findings traceable to evidence
CoverageWhat to askMain domain only, or subdomains too?Why it mattersRisk often sits on forgotten subdomainsHow CyberRank answers itMain domain and its subdomains
Privacy coverageWhat to askAre privacy policies and consent assessed?Why it mattersPrivacy failures carry regulatory riskHow CyberRank answers itPrivacy sub-rating with GDPR and UU PDP indicators
Monitoring frequencyWhat to askHow often are monitored vendors reassessed?Why it mattersDetermines how fast you learn about changeHow CyberRank answers itNightly reassessment
Vendor engagementWhat to askCan vendors see findings, fix them and request re-checks?Why it mattersReduces disputes and speeds remediationHow CyberRank answers itVendor self-service portal
Fourth-party viewWhat to askDoes it show vendors' own suppliers?Why it mattersConcentration risk sits thereHow CyberRank answers itFourth parties with ratings
ReportingWhat to askBoard-level and technical outputs?Why it mattersDifferent audiences need different detailHow CyberRank answers itManagement Report, Cyber Risk Report, Credential Leak Report
Local contextWhat to askLocal language and regulations supported?Why it mattersIndonesian vendors and regulatorsHow CyberRank answers itBahasa Indonesia interface; UU PDP, OJK and BSSN content
IntegrationWhat to askAPI for procurement systems?Why it mattersAvoids manual re-entryHow CyberRank answers itREST API with webhooks

What should you do when a vendor disputes its rating?

Disputes are normal and usually useful. Most stem from asset attribution (a subdomain that is not the vendor's), fixes not yet visible from outside, or findings the vendor considers low risk.

Vendors who want to raise their grade can follow our quick answer on how to improve a security rating. How CyberRank helps: vendors can view ratings, review findings, upload certifications and request re-evaluations through the self-service portal. Work through the five steps below.

  1. Share the evidence. Send the vendor the specific findings, not just the grade.
  2. Agree the facts. Confirm which assets are in scope and which findings are accurate.
  3. Set a remediation plan. Agree deadlines by severity.
  4. Re-assess. Ask for a fresh assessment once fixes are in place.
  5. Record the outcome. Keep the dispute, evidence and result with the vendor file.

How to use security ratings in due diligence: step by step

Tier vendors, set a minimum per tier, rate every candidate, target the questionnaire, write remediation into the contract, monitor and review the trend at renewal.

Steps 3 and 6 below can be automated; tiering, thresholds, contract terms and decisions remain your process. How CyberRank helps: CyberRank automates rating and monitoring and keeps the history you need for renewal reviews.

  1. Tier your vendors by impact on your operations and data.
  2. Set a minimum rating per tier and define the action for vendors below it.
  3. Rate every candidate before contract, using the same method for all.
  4. Target the questionnaire using the findings.
  5. Write remediation into the contract for open findings, with dates.
  6. Monitor after onboarding for rating drops, new breaches and privacy-policy changes; our guide to the rating dashboard and continuous monitoring shows how alerts work.
  7. Review the trend at renewal and record the decision.

How CyberRank supports vendor due diligence

CyberRank is a vendor risk management platform built on the IISRI® methodology. For due diligence it provides the capabilities below.

The full capability list is on the What We Do page. To see the method on a single organisation first, run the free Cybersecurity & Privacy Rating.

  • Outside-in assessment of any organisation from a domain, with no vendor cooperation needed.
  • An AAA–D rating with Security and Privacy sub-ratings, covering the main domain and its subdomains.
  • Impact tier × breach likelihood risk levels and a heat map.
  • A questionnaire builder with evidence upload, expiry dates and automatic sending to vendors below baseline.
  • Certificate Compliance with an AI pre-check (Beta), plus allowed jurisdictions and hosting countries.
  • Nightly reassessment of monitored vendors, with events for rating changes, new data breaches and privacy-policy changes.
  • An Assurance Statement referencing ISO/IEC 27001:2022 controls 5.21 and 5.22, verifiable by QR code.

Where CyberRank does not help

CyberRank cannot decide whether a vendor is acceptable to you; that is a risk decision your organisation owns. It does not review contract clauses, determine whether a vendor falls within NIS2 or DORA scope, or produce a DORA register of information. It cannot see a vendor's internal controls, so a good rating does not replace questionnaires, audit reports or on-site reviews for critical vendors. It also cannot make a vendor fix findings; contract terms and relationship management do that.

Conclusion

Security ratings are most useful in vendor due diligence when they are tied to decisions. Tier vendors, set a minimum rating per tier, rate every candidate before contract, and use the findings to target questionnaires and contract terms. After onboarding, monitor for change and review the trend at renewal. When choosing a provider, favour transparent methods, subdomain and privacy coverage, frequent monitoring and a fair dispute process. CyberRank supports each of these steps with outside-in ratings, questionnaires and nightly monitoring.

About this article

All text in this article reflects CyberRank's own perspective and is provided for general information. It is not legal advice. Product capabilities are described as of 17 November 2026; features marked Beta may change.

References

  1. European Union, Directive (EU) 2022/2555 (NIS2), Article 21(2)(d) and 21(3) (14 December 2022)
  2. European Union, Regulation (EU) 2022/2554 (DORA), Article 28 (14 December 2022)
  3. ISO, ISO/IEC 27001:2022, Annex A controls 5.19–5.22 (October 2022)

Short answers that connect this article with our other guides.

Frequently asked questions

Rate a vendor before you sign

Run the free Cybersecurity & Privacy Rating on any supplier's website and see its AAA–D grade and findings.

Rate a vendor before you sign