Fourth-party risk management: the suppliers behind your vendors

CyberRank Research
Fourth-party risk management is the practice of identifying and assessing the suppliers behind your vendors: their cloud hosts, payment processors, software providers and data centres. A fourth party is one step further from you than a vendor, but an incident there still reaches you through the vendor that depends on it. CyberRank discovers and rates sub-vendors with the same pipeline it uses for direct vendors, so the chain is measured rather than assumed.
TL;DR
- A fourth party is a supplier of your supplier: a cloud host, payment processor or software provider one step further from you.
- An incident at a fourth party reaches you through the vendor that depends on it, so it is still your incident to manage.
- Concentration matters most: when several vendors share one fourth party, a single failure reaches all of them at once.
- You usually cannot contract with fourth parties directly, which is why visibility has to come from outside-in assessment.
- To see fourth parties without asking vendors, use outside-in discovery: CyberRank finds and rates sub-vendors automatically, so they appear in the assessment without a questionnaire.
What is fourth-party risk management?
Fourth-party risk management is identifying and assessing the suppliers behind your vendors, and managing the risk that an incident there reaches you through the vendor that depends on them.
The counting is simple. You are the first party, your vendor is the second, and the vendor's own suppliers are fourth parties in the common usage, even though they sit one step further out. Some organisations call them Nth parties once the chain gets longer.
The risk is not theoretical. A vendor's cloud host, its payment processor and its software providers are all inside the path an attacker can take to reach you, and none of them appear in a vendor list you built from contracts. That is why third-party risk registers understate the chain, and why combined supply-chain risk is reported separately.
How CyberRank helps: CyberRank discovers and rates sub-vendors with the same pipeline it uses for direct vendors, so fourth parties appear in the assessment without anyone having to list them.
| Position | Who it is | Example | How CyberRank helps |
|---|---|---|---|
| First party | Who it isYou | ExampleYour organisation | How CyberRank helpsRates your own posture |
| Third party | Who it isA direct vendor | ExampleA payroll provider you contract with | How CyberRank helpsRates it from its web address |
| Fourth party | Who it isA supplier of your vendor | ExampleThe payroll provider's cloud host | How CyberRank helpsDiscovers and rates it automatically |
| Nth party | Who it isFurther out in the chain | ExampleThe cloud host's own CDN or DNS provider | How CyberRank helpsFolds it in, damped by distance |
Example: one CDN behind four vendors (fictional)
Four of your vendors use the same content delivery network, so an outage or compromise there reaches all four at once.
Each vendor looks independent in your register. The concentration only appears when you map the layer beneath them, and it is the kind of finding a contract review will not produce because you have no contract with the CDN.
The response is not necessarily to replace a vendor. It is to know that four services share a single point of failure, and to decide whether that concentration is acceptable for the impact tier you have assigned. How that concentration changes the number is set out in calculate combined risk across vendors and sub-vendors.
How CyberRank helps: CyberRank identifies the sub-vendors behind each vendor, so shared dependencies become visible as shared nodes rather than as four unrelated suppliers.
Where CyberRank does not help
CyberRank discovers and rates fourth parties from external evidence; it cannot see a private sub-processor list, and it cannot make a fourth party answer for its own controls.
A sub-vendor with no public footprint will be rated on thin evidence, and a supplier that a vendor uses privately may not be discoverable at all. The assessment also cannot compel a fourth party to remediate anything, because you have no relationship with it. This is the supply chain risk we cannot see, and it stays a limit rather than a solved problem.
How CyberRank helps: it makes the discoverable part of the chain visible and reports the nodes that contribute most, which is the part you can act on through your vendors.
References
Frequently asked questions
See the suppliers behind your vendors
Discover and rate the sub-vendors behind each supplier, and see where several of them share one dependency.
See the suppliers behind your vendors